Ruthless Returns
The paperwork

The methods are real

Ruthless Returns is satire, but the dirty tricks are borrowed from reality: fines, verdicts, settlements and perfectly legal industry practice. Here are nine of the cases behind the cards, with sources for every single one.

Case 1 of 9 · In the game

The comment army

Buy the card and sabotage your opponent with bad reviews from customers who never shopped there.

Taiwan, 2013

Samsung hired a comment army

Samsung paid students and bloggers to bash rival HTC in online forums. The agency running the campaign sent Samsung weekly reports with comment tallies and achievement rates.

The Fair Trade Commission

The fine

Taiwan's Fair Trade Commission fined Samsung roughly $340,000.

Trolling run as a consulting project, complete with KPIs and status meetings.

New York, 2013

The fake yogurt shop

New York's attorney general set up a fictional yogurt shop in Brooklyn and asked SEO firms for help with its reputation. 19 companies ended up paying over $350,000 over fake-review schemes, with reviews written for between one and ten dollars apiece.

The troll costs less than the yogurt.

Sources: VentureBeat · Slate · New York Attorney General · NPR

Case 2 of 9 · In the game

The smear campaign

Other people's scandals are your marketing. Buy the card and launch a smear campaign against your opponent.

Southern Denmark, 2014

The new competitor

The ambulance company BIOS won the ambulance tender in the Region of Southern Denmark from Falck. Falck drew up a strategy against its new competitor.

The strategy

Stories fed in secret

Negative stories were covertly fed to the press and to employees, and social media was put to work. Paramedics considering a move to BIOS were deliberately discouraged.

The Competition Council

Pushed out of the country

The Danish Competition Council found that Falck had abused its dominant position to push BIOS out of the country. BIOS went bankrupt along the way.

The bill

A fine of 30 million kroner

Falck accepted a fine of 30 million kroner and had paid 152 million in damages.

This is exactly this card. We just painted it.

Sources: Danish Competition Authority · DR

Case 3 of 9 · In the game

Upselling without consent

Upgrade the customer without asking, and send the bill as thanks for their trust. The card pays 2M for every salesperson you have.

USA, 2002 to 2016

Targets nobody could meet honestly

Wells Fargo measured its branches on products sold per customer. So the employees met the targets dishonestly: they opened accounts in customers' names without asking and ordered cards nobody had requested, to hit the sales goals and collect bonuses.

The count

Over two million accounts and cards

At least 1.5 million deposit accounts and 565,000 credit cards may have been opened without consent. Some customers were charged fees on accounts they did not know they had.

September 2016

The regulator's largest fine

The consumer regulator CFPB imposed a $100 million fine, the largest it had ever imposed. By then the bank had fired at least 5,300 employees, including branch managers and their managers. The chief executive left a month later.

February 2020

3 billion dollars

Wells Fargo paid $3 billion to close the criminal and civil investigations, and admitted pressuring employees toward unrealistic sales goals.

Sources: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 2016 · US Department of Justice, 2020

Case 4 of 9 · In the game

Lock the team in

With a non-compete clause, golden handcuffs or executive contracts, your employees cannot be poached.

Silicon Valley

The deal to hold back

Apple, Google, Intel and Adobe made secret agreements not to recruit each other's employees. It held down wages for tens of thousands of engineers.

2015

The settlement

A judge approved a $415 million settlement for roughly 64,000 workers.

In the game, it costs a card to lock in your own employees. The companies locked in each other's with a secret deal. That was a cartel.

Europe, 2025

The first of its kind

From 2018 to 2022 Delivery Hero and Glovo agreed not to recruit each other's employees and divided markets between them. In June 2025 the European Commission fined them a total of €329 million in a settlement, its first ever fine for a no-poach agreement.

Sources: TechCrunch · NBC News · Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer · Slaughter and May

Case 5 of 9 · In the game

Green image

A polished green image makes the next shitstorm bounce off, regardless of what goes on behind the facade.

2019

Europe's lowest emissions

Ryanair advertised itself as Europe's lowest emissions airline, based among other things on an efficiency ranking from 2011.

Meanwhile

In the company of coal plants

Ryanair had become the first airline to enter the top ten emitters in the EU's carbon trading system. The rest of the list was coal plants.

The advertising authority

Banned as misleading

The UK advertising authority banned the campaign. The sanction was that the ads could not run again in that form.

That was the entire sanction.

Sources: BBC · The ASA ruling

Case 6 of 9 · In the game

Life insurance on the staff

Some employees create the most value once they stop showing up. The worse the work environment, the more the card pays: 2M for every missing step, at once and again every year.

USA, mid-1990s

More than 300,000 policies

Walmart took out life insurance on more than 300,000 of its employees, from cashiers upwards, naming itself as the beneficiary. The employees were typically not told.

The industry's own name

Dead peasant insurance

When an employee died, the money went to the company, not the family. The point was a tax deduction on the loan-financed premiums, and when Congress closed it, Walmart stopped in 2000, saying the scheme was losing money.

Texas, 2004

The money belonged to the estates

The appeals court found that Walmart had no insurable interest in the lives of ordinary employees. Walmart settled for $10.3 million in Texas and $5.1 million in Oklahoma.

In the game, the insurance pays most when the work environment is worst. It did in real life too. Nobody just wrote it on the card.

Sources: WFSU (2010) · Workday Magazine on the ruling · Law360 on the settlement

Case 7 of 9 · In the game

Hire the minister's son

Connections win tenders: with the minister's son on the payroll, your bid counts 1M higher. And if you get cheated, there is another card for that: the lawsuit.

Bill 1 · The officials

Bribes for contracts

For years Ericsson used intermediaries and off-the-books funds to bribe officials in countries including Djibouti, China, Vietnam and Indonesia. In Djibouti around $2.1 million went to senior officials for a contract worth about €20 million.

Bill 2 · The authorities

More than a billion dollars

In 2019 Ericsson admitted the conduct to the US authorities and paid more than a billion dollars to settle.

Bill 3 · The competitor

Nokia sends the bill

Finland's Nokia claimed damages, and in 2021 Ericsson settled and paid €80 million. The other terms are confidential.

First Ericsson paid the officials, then the authorities, and finally the competitor.

Sources: US Department of Justice, 2019 · Ericsson's announcement of the settlement · Euronews (Reuters)

Case 8 of 9 · In the game

Bribe the judge

The card gives you legal expertise and money for every lawsuit you win.

Luzerne County, Pennsylvania

The new juvenile detention centre

President Judge Michael Conahan and juvenile court judge Mark Ciavarella shut the county's old juvenile detention centre and signed an agreement guaranteeing a new, private facility $1.314 million a year to house the county's young offenders.

The money

About $2.8 million

The builder paid the judges more than two million dollars in so-called referral fees. The co-owner booked his payments as rent on an uninhabitable condominium in Florida. In total the two judges received about $2.8 million.

The courtroom

Half without a lawyer

Ciavarella ran a zero-tolerance juvenile court. About half the young people appeared before him without a lawyer, nearly ten times the state average. One teenager got three months for making a spoof MySpace profile of an assistant principal.

The sentences

28 years and 17 and a half

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court vacated Ciavarella's rulings from 2003 to 2008. In 2011 Ciavarella was sentenced to 28 years in prison and Conahan to 17 and a half, and in 2022 the two were ordered to pay $206 million in damages to around 300 of the young people.

Ciavarella has called the money a legal finder's fee and denied locking up young people for money.

Sources: US District Court, Middle District of Pennsylvania · NBC News (AP), 2022 · Juvenile Law Center · Digital Media Law Project · CBS News (AP), 2011

Case 9 of 9 · In the game

Recruit from the ministry

Buy knowledge of the system by hiring the system. Or lend an expert to the ministry and get a friend back.

Brussels, 2016

From the Commission to Goldman Sachs

Former European Commission president José Manuel Barroso became chairman of Goldman Sachs International, advising on Brexit. It triggered a case at the EU ombudsman, a petition with 80,000 signatures and longer cooling-off periods for departing commissioners.

Berlin, 2005

The pipeline

A few weeks before Gerhard Schröder stepped down as German chancellor, the deal for the Nord Stream gas pipeline was signed with Schröder and Putin looking on. Shortly after he left office, it was announced that he would chair the company behind the pipeline, controlled by Russia's Gazprom.

The door barely had time to swing.

Europe, 2019

From the supervisor to the lobby

Adam Farkas went from executive director of the European Banking Authority, EBA, to chief executive of the financial industry's lobby group AFME. The European Ombudsman found in 2020 that the EBA should have forbidden the move.

From the supervisor to those who work on the supervisor.

Sources: LSE · Corporate Europe Observatory · BBC · Alliance for Securing Democracy · European Ombudsman · Agence Europe

And one last one

Three Way Banana Split

Currency traders from five major banks spent years coordinating trades and exchanging sensitive information in private chatrooms. In 2019 the European Commission fined them a combined €1.07 billion. The chatrooms were called, among other things, Three Way Banana Split, Essex Express and Semi Grumpy Old Men.

Satire is redundant here. The names were their own.

Sources: European Commission · CNBC

The card index

Reality ships more expansions than we do

The full card index has 46 entries, all with sources: paid trolls, rented protesters, cartels and tax havens included. It will never be complete.

The full card index

46 entries, each with its sources. You have just seen the nine marked in gold.

    All cases are described from publicly available sources such as fines, verdicts, settlements and press coverage. Where a case was dropped, settled or is still running, we say so, and an accusation is not a conviction. None of the companies, shows, parties or people mentioned have any connection to Ruthless Returns. The game is satire: the methods are real, the companies in the game are not.

    Try the tricks yourself. It's only a game.

    South Harbour StudiosRuthless Returns · Regnskabets Time · A game by Thomas Lay & Diana C. L. · © 2026 South Harbour Studios · Privacy